Ready to buy a home in Nutley, NJ?
Are you searching for a home in Nutley, New Jersey?
The Nutley real estate market currently offers everything from entry-level condos and traditional single-family homes to multi-family properties, luxury residences and new construction. Prices currently range from the low $200,000s to more than $1.4 million.
Below is a roundup of homes publicly advertised for sale in Nutley as of July 22, 2026. Prices and availability can change quickly, so buyers should confirm the latest information before scheduling a showing or making an offer.
640 Franklin Avenue, Unit 2 — $234,000
This one-bedroom, one-bath condominium offers approximately 538 square feet of living space. It may be worth considering for buyers seeking a smaller residence, a Nutley pied-à-terre or an alternative to renting.
Asking price: $234,000
38 Orchard Street — $350,000
A three-bedroom, one-bath single-family home at one of the lower asking prices currently available in Nutley. Buyers looking for an opportunity to renovate, personalize or enter the Nutley housing market may want to investigate this property further.
Asking price: $350,000
25 River Road, Apartment B11 — $429,990
This three-bedroom, one-and-a-half-bath condominium or townhome offers a lower-maintenance ownership option. Its combination of three bedrooms and a price below many Nutley single-family homes may attract buyers comparing houses with condominium living.
Asking price: $429,990
207 Van Winkle Avenue — $499,900
This three-bedroom, two-bath single-family home is positioned just below the $500,000 mark. It offers buyers an opportunity to own a detached home in Nutley without entering the town’s higher luxury price ranges.
Asking price: $499,900
24 Harvard Street — $519,900
A three-bedroom, one-and-a-half-bath single-family home offering a traditional residential layout. This property may appeal to buyers searching for a manageable home at a mid-$500,000 price point.
Asking price: $519,900
42 Hay Avenue — $525,000
This two-bedroom, two-bath single-family home could be an interesting option for buyers who prefer fewer bedrooms but still want two full bathrooms and the privacy of a detached residence.
Asking price: $525,000
134 Kenzel Avenue — $549,999
Offering four bedrooms and one bathroom, this single-family home provides more sleeping space than many similarly priced properties. Buyers should consider whether the bedroom count and overall layout fit their needs and renovation plans.
Asking price: $549,999
64 Conover Avenue — $550,000
This three-bedroom, one-bath single-family home offers approximately 1,224 square feet of living space. It presents a straightforward Nutley ownership opportunity for buyers who value a detached home over a condominium or townhome.
Asking price: $550,000
25 Woodland Avenue — $599,000
A three-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bath single-family home positioned just under $600,000. The additional bathrooms may make this property attractive to buyers comparing it with older homes that have more limited bathroom space.
Asking price: $599,000
87 Edison Avenue — $599,900
This three-bedroom, one-and-a-half-bath single-family home enters the market just below $600,000. Buyers looking for a traditional Nutley home within this price range should place it on their comparison list.
Asking price: $599,900
215 Barringer Drive, Unit 215 — $609,000
This two-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bath townhome offers approximately 1,790 square feet of living space. It combines a substantial interior footprint with the lower-maintenance character many townhome buyers prefer.
Asking price: $609,000
129 Pake Street — $610,000
Offering four bedrooms and two bathrooms, this single-family home provides a practical bedroom count at a price slightly above $600,000. It may appeal to buyers who need flexible space for offices, guests or additional living areas.
Asking price: $610,000
17 Princeton Street — $625,000
This three-bedroom, two-bath single-family home offers a balanced bedroom and bathroom configuration. It falls within one of Nutley’s most competitive price ranges, where correctly priced homes can attract attention quickly.
Asking price: $625,000
50 Ernest Street — $635,000
A four-bedroom, two-bath single-family property offering additional room compared with many three-bedroom homes. Buyers seeking usable space without moving into the upper-$700,000 market may want to consider it.
Asking price: $635,000
419 Hartford Drive — $639,000
This two-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bath condominium offers approximately 2,010 square feet of living space. The large interior footprint may appeal to buyers downsizing from a house without wanting to sacrifice substantial living space.
Asking price: $639,000
23 Princeton Street — $639,999
This three-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bath single-family home offers a flexible layout and the convenience of an additional half bathroom. It represents another opportunity in Nutley’s active mid-$600,000 market.
Asking price: $639,999
7 Freeman Place — $645,000
A four-bedroom, two-bath multi-family property that may appeal to owner-occupants or buyers exploring rental-income possibilities. Any buyer should independently review the property’s legal use, leases, expenses and zoning.
Asking price: $645,000
451 Hartford Drive — $648,900
This two-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bath condominium offers a townhome-style alternative to a detached residence. It may work well for buyers seeking multiple bathrooms, defined living areas and less exterior maintenance.
Asking price: $648,900
214 Swathmore Drive — $649,000
Offering approximately 1,800 square feet, two bedrooms and two-and-a-half bathrooms, this condominium provides a generous amount of interior space. It may appeal to buyers looking for a larger condominium within Nutley.
Asking price: $649,000
537 Coventry Drive, Unit 5038 — $649,000
This two-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bath condominium offers another option within Nutley’s established residential communities. Buyers comparing condominium developments should review the association fees, amenities and financial documents.
Asking price: $649,000
569 Coventry Drive, Unit 5070 — $659,000
A two-bedroom, two-bath condominium priced in the upper $600,000 range. It may suit buyers who prioritize interior comfort and community living over maintaining a traditional detached property.
Asking price: $659,000
288 Harrison Street — $665,000
This three-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bath single-family home offers the bathroom count many modern buyers seek. Its price places it squarely within Nutley’s highly competitive middle market.
Asking price: $665,000
151 Conover Avenue — $689,000
A three-bedroom, two-bath multi-family home offering potential flexibility for an owner-occupant or investor. Buyers should verify unit configuration, current occupancy, rental information and municipal approvals.
Asking price: $689,000
18 Carrie Court — $695,000
This three-bedroom, two-bath single-family home is located on a street with a more private residential feel. It may interest buyers searching near the $700,000 level without crossing into the higher luxury category.
Asking price: $695,000
11 Hampton Place — $699,000
Offering four bedrooms and two bathrooms, this single-family home provides added flexibility for buyers needing more than the typical three-bedroom layout. Its asking price keeps it just below $700,000.
Asking price: $699,000
424 Hartford Drive — $699,000
This two-bedroom, three-and-a-half-bath condominium stands out for its unusually generous bathroom count. It may appeal to buyers seeking a spacious, multi-level residence without taking on a traditional single-family property.
Asking price: $699,000
324 Winthrop Drive — $699,900
This two-bedroom, three-and-a-half-bath townhome offers approximately 2,010 square feet. Its combination of interior space and multiple bathrooms makes it a strong alternative to similarly priced detached homes.
Asking price: $699,900
242 Prospect Street — $699,999
A three-bedroom, three-bath multi-family property offering approximately 1,577 square feet. Buyers interested in multi-family ownership should review the unit setup, income potential, operating expenses and legal occupancy.
Asking price: $699,999
33 Myrtle Avenue — $699,999
This three-bedroom, two-bath single-family home offers a traditional Nutley ownership opportunity near the $700,000 mark. Buyers should compare its condition, storage, property improvements and outdoor space with other homes in the same price category.
Asking price: $699,999
84 Howard Place — $729,999
Offering approximately 2,100 square feet, three bedrooms and three bathrooms, this single-family home provides a larger interior than many competing three-bedroom properties.
Asking price: $729,999
184 Beech Street — $739,000
This four-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bath single-family residence offers a practical combination of bedroom space and bathrooms. It may be a fit for buyers looking in the mid-$700,000 segment of the Nutley market.
Asking price: $739,000
8 Witherspoon Street — $749,000
A four-bedroom, two-bath multi-family home that may offer both living space and income potential. Buyers should carefully investigate each unit, legal use, tenancy, utilities and operating costs.
Asking price: $749,000
17 Brown Street — $749,000
This three-bedroom, two-bath single-family home is positioned in the mid-$700,000 range. Buyers should evaluate the property’s renovations, overall condition and finished living areas when comparing its value.
Asking price: $749,000
18 Hudson Street — $749,000
Offering four bedrooms and two-and-a-half bathrooms, this single-family home provides a versatile layout. The combination of four bedrooms and multiple bathrooms places it among Nutley’s more substantial mid-priced offerings.
Asking price: $749,000
115 Coeyman Avenue — $749,000
This five-bedroom, four-bath single-family home stands out for its bedroom and bathroom count. Buyers needing substantial interior flexibility may find it compelling, but should confirm the latest price and status because public portals have displayed conflicting information.
Asking price shown: $749,000
77 Columbia Avenue — $749,990
This two-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bath single-family home offers approximately 2,056 square feet. Although it has fewer bedrooms, its larger interior footprint may appeal to buyers prioritizing spacious rooms and living areas.
Asking price: $749,990
33 Mapes Avenue — $750,000
Offering five bedrooms and two-and-a-half bathrooms, this single-family home provides room for multiple uses. Buyers seeking additional bedrooms around the $750,000 mark should investigate its layout and overall condition.
Asking price: $750,000
29 Fischer Avenue — $769,000
This three-bedroom, three-and-a-half-bath single-family home offers an unusually strong bathroom count for a three-bedroom property. It may interest buyers who value private bathrooms, guest accommodations and flexible finished space.
Asking price: $769,000
97 Conover Avenue — $774,900
A four-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bath townhouse offering an alternative to a traditional detached property. Buyers should confirm the exact ownership structure, association responsibilities and whether any monthly fees apply.
Asking price: $774,900
38 Alexander Avenue — $775,000
This six-bedroom, four-and-a-half-bath single-family home offers approximately 4,304 square feet on roughly 0.41 acres. Its size and bedroom count make it one of the more substantial properties currently advertised in this price range.
Asking price: $775,000
215 Park Avenue — $785,000
Offering five bedrooms and four bathrooms, this single-family home provides significant interior flexibility. Buyers seeking several bedrooms and bathrooms below $800,000 may find this property particularly noteworthy.
Asking price: $785,000
81 Hastings Avenue — $799,000
This four-bedroom, three-bath single-family home is positioned just below $800,000. It offers the kind of bedroom and bathroom configuration buyers often seek when moving into Nutley’s upper-middle price range.
Asking price: $799,000
98 King Street — $799,999
A three-bedroom, three-bath multi-family property offering potential owner-occupancy or investment possibilities. Buyers should verify all rents, leases, expenses, utility arrangements and municipal records.
Asking price: $799,999
251 High Street — $849,900
This four-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bath single-family home sits on a lot reported at approximately 9,085 square feet. It may appeal to buyers who place additional value on outdoor space and a larger residential parcel.
Asking price: $849,900
21 Ravine Avenue — $889,900
Offering three bedrooms and three bathrooms, this single-family residence is positioned near the $900,000 level. Buyers should compare its lot, condition, renovations and interior space with other upper-tier Nutley homes.
Asking price: $889,900
151 Church Street — $900,000
This four-bedroom, four-bath single-family home offers a strong bathroom-to-bedroom ratio. It enters Nutley’s luxury market with a layout that may accommodate guests, home offices and multiple living arrangements.
Asking price: $900,000
621 Bloomfield Avenue — $959,000
This four-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bath single-family residence offers a substantial lot and generously sized rooms. It may appeal to buyers seeking space, long-term potential and the opportunity to personalize a larger Nutley home.
Asking price: $959,000
23 Park Drive — $965,000
A three-bedroom, two-and-a-half-bath single-family home positioned within Nutley’s luxury market. Buyers should examine its architectural details, updates, garage, location and overall condition when evaluating the asking price.
Asking price: $965,000
9 Memphis Avenue — $999,000
This six-bedroom, three-bath multi-family property offers approximately 2,450 square feet. Buyers looking for a larger income-producing or owner-occupied property should review its unit configuration and complete financial information.
Asking price: $999,000
141 Coeyman Avenue — $1,050,000
Offering approximately 2,500 square feet, four bedrooms and two-and-a-half bathrooms, this single-family home enters the million-dollar segment of the Nutley market. Its lot, renovations and overall finish should be carefully compared with other luxury offerings.
Asking price: $1,050,000
56 Povershon Road — $1,125,000
This new-construction single-family home offers five bedrooms and four-and-a-half bathrooms. Buyers seeking modern construction, contemporary systems and a substantial bedroom count may want to place this property near the top of their tour list.
Asking price: $1,125,000
36 Harrison Street — $1,196,500
Offering approximately 4,180 square feet, eight bedrooms and four bathrooms, this home provides an exceptional amount of interior space. Buyers should verify the property’s permitted use, bedroom configuration and any multi-generational or multi-unit possibilities.
Asking price: $1,196,500
96 Hillside Avenue — $1,435,000
This nine-bedroom multi-family property offers approximately 4,450 square feet and more than four bathrooms. It is currently one of the highest-priced residential offerings in Nutley and may attract buyers focused on larger multi-family assets.
Asking price: $1,435,000
Thinking About Buying a Home in Nutley?
Nutley remains one of Northern New Jersey’s most closely watched housing markets. The town offers a wide range of property styles and price points, but inventory, status and asking prices can change from one day to the next.
Online listings can show you what is available. They cannot tell you which homes are correctly priced, which properties may have hidden issues, or where there may be an opportunity to negotiate.
For current availability, private showings and a professional comparison of the homes that best fit your needs, contact:
Matthew De Fede
Broker/Owner — Realty Executives Elite Homes
Nutley, New Jersey
Listing information was gathered from publicly available real estate portals and was reviewed on July 22, 2026. Properties are represented by multiple real estate brokerages. Realty Executives Elite Homes and Matthew De Fede are not the listing broker for every property included in this roundup. Information is deemed reliable but is not guaranteed. Prices, features and availability are subject to change. Equal Housing Opportunity.